task icon Task

Improve Review Draft

Requirements
Draft performance review text
2

Analyze the draft for:

SPECIFICITY

  • Are examples concrete or vague?
  • Is impact quantified where possible?
  • Can the reader picture what happened?

BALANCE

  • Fair mix of strengths and growth areas?
  • Does it feel constructive or punitive?
  • Are growth areas actionable?

TONE

  • Professional and respectful?
  • Direct without being harsh?
  • Motivating rather than deflating?

ACTIONABILITY

  • Clear next steps?
  • Specific enough to act on?
  • Goals are measurable?
3

Provide specific feedback on the draft:

  • What's working well
  • What needs more specificity
  • Suggestions for better framing
  • Any red flags (vague, harsh, or unhelpful language)
4

Offer a revised version with improvements.
Explain key changes and why they matter.

                    To run this task you must have the following required information:

> Draft performance review text

If you don't have all of this information, exit here and respond asking for any extra information you require, and instructions to run this task again with ALL required information.

---

You MUST use a todo list to complete these steps in order. Never move on to one step if you haven't completed the previous step. If you have multiple read steps in a row, read them all at once (in parallel).

Add all steps to your todo list now and begin executing.

## Steps

1. [Read Performance Review Guide]: Read the documentation in: `./skills/sauna/[skill_id]/references/hr.review.guide.md`

2. Analyze the draft for:

SPECIFICITY
- Are examples concrete or vague?
- Is impact quantified where possible?
- Can the reader picture what happened?

BALANCE
- Fair mix of strengths and growth areas?
- Does it feel constructive or punitive?
- Are growth areas actionable?

TONE
- Professional and respectful?
- Direct without being harsh?
- Motivating rather than deflating?

ACTIONABILITY
- Clear next steps?
- Specific enough to act on?
- Goals are measurable?


3. Provide specific feedback on the draft:
- What's working well
- What needs more specificity
- Suggestions for better framing
- Any red flags (vague, harsh, or unhelpful language)


4. Offer a revised version with improvements.
Explain key changes and why they matter.